A neighbor of Nancy Guthrie believes she may have unknowingly crossed paths with the person who later abducted the 84-year-old — and her account is now fueling a new push for evidence in the case tied to Today show host Savannah Guthrie’s missing mother.
Aldine Meister, who has lived in the Tucson area for more than 30 years, told NewsNation correspondent Brian Entin that she noticed a man in the neighborhood on the morning of Jan. 11 — nearly three weeks before Guthrie disappeared.
And it wasn’t just a passing glance.
“He wasn’t going terribly quickly like a normal person who’s getting exercise,” Meister said. “He was kind of going slowly, and when he walked by this street, he really took a long look at it.”
Meister said the man stood out because he didn’t seem like someone out for a casual stroll. She described him as hunched over, with a baseball cap pulled low on his face, and acting like he was checking his surroundings.
“He was kind of looking around, and he just didn’t fit,” she said.
In a separate interview earlier this month, Meister said the person she saw appeared to be on the younger side and gave off a strong sense that he had a reason for being there.
“He just didn’t look like he was going out for a walk,” she added.
Meister told Entin she mentioned the encounter to her husband at the time because it rattled her — but she didn’t report it then. Only after Guthrie vanished did she contact the FBI about what she’d seen.
Now, the FBI is asking neighbors to turn over any doorbell camera footage from the date Meister says she spotted the suspicious man. Authorities haven’t confirmed whether the footage request is directly tied to her account, but the timing is hard to ignore.
Nancy Guthrie was last seen on Jan. 31 at her home in Tucson. She was reported missing Feb. 1 after family members said she didn’t show up for church.
In February, investigators released video from Guthrie’s Nest doorbell camera showing a masked figure outside the home. The person appears to be wearing a backpack and gloves — and is seen with what looked like a holstered gun.
Detectives have questioned multiple persons of interest, but they still haven’t publicly identified a suspect.
Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos, who is leading the investigation, offered a cautious but confident update, telling reporters investigators are closer than ever to cracking the case.
“We’ve got a lot of intel,” Nanos said, while stressing that much of the investigation will remain out of public view.
He did not give a timeline for finding Guthrie — and previously suggested the search could take a long time, potentially even years.
For now, the case remains wide open, but Meister’s unsettling “I saw him before” moment is giving investigators — and an anxious neighborhood — a fresh thread to pull.


I still hope that they find her alive.🙏❤️