An argument over personal belongings ended in tragedy for a Washington, D.C., family after one 16-year-old twin was fatally shot and his identical brother was accused of pulling the trigger.
Now, nearly a month later, Jamari Young is facing a second-degree murder charge in the death of his twin brother, Jabrell Young. But their devastated mother insists the shooting was a terrible accident, saying her sons were inseparable and would never intentionally hurt one another.
The tragedy unfolded on the morning of October 25 inside the family’s home on 46th Street in Northeast Washington.
According to court documents, the brothers began arguing after Jabrell allegedly entered Jamari’s bedroom and touched his belongings. Their mother, Chantel Poe, was awakened by the commotion and heard one of the boys yelling about someone touching his things.
When she went downstairs to investigate, she found the twins physically fighting outside their basement bedrooms.
Poe attempted to separate her sons, positioning herself between them. Moments later, she heard a gunshot and turned to see Jamari holding a firearm. When she looked back at Jabrell, he had collapsed.
What happened next was particularly heartbreaking.
“I didn’t mean to! It just went off! I didn’t mean to! I’m sorry, Ma!” Jamari allegedly cried, according to the court documents.
His distraught mother screamed at him to leave the house as he continued apologizing.
Police arrived around 8:36 a.m. and discovered Jabrell suffering from gunshot wounds. Despite efforts to save him, the teenager was pronounced dead at the scene.
Investigators later determined that Jabrell had been shot twice in the chest, a finding prosecutors have pointed to while challenging the family’s account that the shooting was accidental.
The tragedy has left relatives struggling to understand how two brothers described as being “thick as thieves” could become involved in such a devastating confrontation.
The investigation also uncovered another disturbing detail. Police found a loaded 9mm handgun wrapped in a blanket beneath a parked vehicle outside the home after another person was reportedly seen moving the blanket there.
Authorities said the weapon was linked to a separate shooting in Washington in July. However, investigators have not established publicly whether that handgun was involved in Jabrell’s death.
Jamari left the home following the shooting and remained out of police custody for more than three weeks before his arrest on November 18.
He was charged as an adult with second-degree murder while armed.
During a November 19 court hearing, prosecutors argued that the evidence supported a murder charge despite the family’s insistence that the shooting was unintentional.
Magistrate Judge Dorsey Jones acknowledged that he did not believe Jamari necessarily intended to kill his brother but determined there was sufficient evidence to support the charge at this stage of the proceedings.
The teenager was ordered held without bond, with a preliminary hearing scheduled for December 7.
Outside the courthouse, Poe passionately defended her surviving son, rejecting suggestions that he deliberately killed his brother.
“This is an accident!” she told reporters, adding that her sons were best friends who loved each other.
For the family, the tragedy has created an agonizing situation. One son has been laid to rest, while the other faces a potentially lengthy prison sentence over the death of the person who had been by his side since birth.
Whether the shooting was accidental or criminally reckless remains a central question as the case moves through the courts.

