The Myth of ‘Pope Joan’: How a Medieval Legend Became a Feminist Fantasy

As the world watches the Catholic Church prepare to elect the next pope after the death of Pope Francis, one thing remains crystal clear: the next leader of the Church will be a man — just as tradition, doctrine, and history demand.

But that hasn’t stopped internet theorists from resurrecting an old myth: the so-called “Pope Joan,” a woman alleged to have secretly ruled the Vatican under disguise. The claim? That centuries ago, a woman outsmarted the Church and became pope.

The truth? It’s little more than a medieval fairy tale — and one modern feminists refuse to let die.

Where Did the Story of Pope Joan Come From?

According to legend, a brilliant young woman living around the 9th century disguised herself as a man, rose through Church ranks, and was elected pope under the name John VIII. Her secret supposedly unraveled when she gave birth during a public procession.

It’s a story that captured imaginations — and one that critics of Church tradition still cling to today.

“Pope Joan is an invention born out of anti-Catholic sentiment,” says Dr. Martin Reyes, a Church historian based in Virginia. “It was weaponized during the Reformation to smear the Vatican.”

Indeed, early Protestant reformers like David Blondel in the 1600s popularized the story to attack Rome’s credibility. Blondel’s 1647 tract, Familiar Enlightenment of the Question, argued against the authenticity of Joan’s tale, labeling it a “pious fraud” — fabricated by enemies of the Church.

The Church’s Verdict: No Evidence, No Joan

Serious scholars have long since buried the story. The Oxford Dictionary of Popes states flatly: “There is no contemporary evidence for a female Pope at any of the dates suggested.”

Even liberal historians concede that Pope Joan’s existence is highly unlikely. Records from the 9th century — when Church bureaucracy was already rigorous — make no mention of such a scandal.

Italian friar Onofrio Panvinio argued as far back as the 16th century that the legend may have arisen from the mistaken identity of a mistress linked to the scandal-ridden Pope John XII, not a secret female pope.

Modern Feminists Keep the Fantasy Alive

Still, the myth has taken on a second life in modern times — now hailed as a symbol of supposed “patriarchal oppression.” Films like Pope Joan (2009) have romanticized the legend, ignoring centuries of historical debunking.

“It’s ironic,” Reyes notes. “The same activists who demand ‘truth’ from religious institutions are perfectly happy to promote a proven fabrication if it suits their political agenda.”

Why a Woman Will Never Be Pope

The Catholic Church has been unwavering: women cannot be ordained priests, and therefore, they cannot become pope. The reason is not “sexism” but theology. Christ chose male apostles, and the Church is bound to follow His example, not change it to fit modern fashions.

Pope Benedict XVI made it clear during his papacy: “The Church has no authority whatsoever to confer priestly ordination on women.”

For many Catholics, this isn’t discrimination — it’s faithfulness.

As cardinals gather in the Sistine Chapel for the coming conclave, don’t expect a surprise. Despite the noise, the tradition stands strong — and Pope Joan remains what she’s always been: a myth designed to undermine a Church that refuses to bend to political whims.

By What's Up Today Editorial Team

The What’s Up Today Editorial Team covers breaking news, crime, pop culture, celebrity news, viral stories, human-interest features and other timely events from across the United States and around the world. Our reporting is based on information from official statements, court and public records, law enforcement agencies, government sources, primary-source social media posts, interviews and established local and national news organizations. Whenever possible, we verify key details through original sources and add useful context such as timelines, prior developments, court dates, official responses and what may happen next. We aim to clearly distinguish confirmed facts from allegations, opinion and speculation, especially in stories involving criminal investigations, lawsuits or developing events. If new information becomes available, our stories may be updated to reflect the latest verified details. Readers can contact the What’s Up Today Editorial Team through our Contact Us page with corrections, story tips or questions about our coverage.

One thought on “The Myth of ‘Pope Joan’: How a Medieval Legend Became a Feminist Fantasy”
  1. Jesus was a Jew. He chose twelve apostles who were Jews. Simon Peter was a Jew. Moses was a Jew. Pontius Pilate was Roman. He ordered Christ’s crucifixion. Roman’s were considered Gentiles. Now how is it that my Lord and Savior Jesus created a successor to Simon Peter to a Roman Church?

Leave a Reply