A prominent former pastor of one of America’s most powerful megachurches has been convicted of stalking and breaking into the home of a female congregant—twice—after an eight-year campaign of obsession, intimidation, and control.
Sergio Guardia, 49, once held a position of spiritual authority at Thomas Road Baptist Church, a national religious powerhouse founded by the late Jerry Falwell. Now, he’s a convicted felon—found guilty last week by a Lynchburg jury on two counts of burglary and one count of stalking.
But for Marie Columna, the 43-year-old mother of two who Guardia tormented for nearly a decade, justice still feels out of reach.
“I’m terrified. He doesn’t care about laws or consequences,” Columna told American Ledger in an exclusive interview. “He had a protective order, and he broke into my home like it meant nothing.”
A Trusted Pastor Turned Predator
Columna met Guardia in 2007 while attending a Spanish-language service at Thomas Road Baptist Church. After her marriage ended in 2011, she says Guardia and his wife encouraged her to stay active in the church.
But behind the pastoral smile was something darker.
“He started telling me not to talk to men. Then it was, ‘delete them from Facebook.’ I thought it was spiritual advice. It wasn’t,” she said.
When she refused his romantic advances, things escalated.
“He started showing up uninvited with groceries when my kids weren’t home. He would park outside my house. One day, I found him sitting in my living room, using my laptop,” she recalled.
She asked him to stop. He didn’t.
“He told me he was in love with me. I told him to leave and never come back. He just kept coming.”
Despite moving multiple times and blocking him on all platforms, she says he kept finding her.
“It felt like I couldn’t hide from him. I was scared and exhausted.”
Caught on Camera: The Break-Ins
On November 10, 2023, while visiting a friend out of state, Columna received a chilling phone notification. Her security camera had been triggered—someone was inside her Lynchburg home.
The footage showed a man creeping through her dark kitchen, using the flashlight on his phone.
“It was him. Sergio. He knew exactly where to go. He’d clearly been inside before,” she said.
The very next night, another alert: Guardia again entered her home—this time through the basement, which is her teenage daughter’s bedroom.
“He got in the same way. My daughter’s friends sometimes use that door. The key was right there. He knew where to find it.”
Columna immediately contacted police.
Lynchburg officers arrived, guns drawn. They searched the house, closets, and even the backyard—but Guardia was gone.
Still, within two hours, he was identified, charged, and arrested.
A Church With Influence—and Silence
Thomas Road Baptist Church, now closely tied to Liberty University, has been long considered a conservative stronghold and training ground for future leaders.
But Columna believes the church’s power helped shield Guardia for years.
“They never took me seriously. I went to leadership when his behavior got weird back in 2016. Nothing happened,” she said.
Even after the criminal charges, the church refused to distance itself. Executive Pastor Matt Wilmington—still employed by the church—appeared in court as a character witness for Guardia at his bond hearing.
“That hurt the most. I’m testifying about how this man broke into my house, and the church sends someone to defend him.”
Thomas Road Baptist Church declined to respond to multiple requests for comment.
Digital Intrusions and a Chilling Pattern
Columna suspects Guardia’s obsession wasn’t limited to physical visits.
She received email alerts about login attempts from IP addresses linked to Liberty University. When she reviewed her account, she found a Liberty email set as her Yahoo recovery option—one she never added.
“I removed it, and the login attempts stopped. That’s how deep he went,” she said.
Still Living in Fear
Despite the guilty verdict, Guardia was released on a mere $5,000 bond. He served only four days in jail. His pre-sentencing hearing isn’t until August 20.
“He’s out walking free. I have a piece of paper and cameras. That’s all,” Columna said, referencing her protective order.
She worries that supporters of the church still view Guardia as a victim.
“I want them to hear my voice. A jury found him guilty on all counts. He’s a felon. I’m not making this up,” she said. “This isn’t just about me. This is about how churches protect predators because they’re afraid of scandal.”
“Women and children are the ones who suffer. And too often, no one listens—until it’s too late.”

Those patronizing megachurches are, at best, being fleeced.
This is why I have my connection with God outside of a church…Too many religions cover up for folks like this and refuse to realize that they are putting others in harm’s way. If they were “right” with God, then they would have these PREDATORS removed from any position, fired and ARRESTED…But too many are just a front for someone with a “God” complex and are deeply, deeply disturbed. Anyone remember Jim Jones? I rest my case…