Sheriff’s Department ‘Embarrassed’ Over Botched Guthrie Case

SOURCE: @SAVANNAHGUTHRIE/INSTAGRAM; NEWS 4 TUCSON KVOA-TV

The disappearance of Nancy Guthrie has taken a dark new turn — and now the spotlight is shifting from the suspected kidnapper to the man in charge of finding her.

Behind closed doors, frustration inside the Pima County Sheriff’s Department is reportedly boiling over, with insiders blasting Sheriff Chris Nanos for what they claim is a disastrous handling of the high-profile case that has gripped the nation.

“We have no faith in Chris Nanos,” one source close to the investigation said bluntly, as the search for the 84-year-old drags past the two-month mark with no arrests, no confirmed suspects, and few answers.

The backlash is intense — and deeply personal.

“He ruined a great department,” the insider claimed, adding that morale among deputies has sunk to what they describe as an all-time low. “This is the lowest I’ve ever seen it. There’s embarrassment — a lot of it.”

According to the source, tensions have been fueled in part by Nanos’ public comments and media appearances, which some within the department believe have only made matters worse.

“Shut your mouth. Stop talking,” the insider said, describing the sentiment among rank-and-file officers. “Why is he out there saying that?”

The criticism comes as the case itself grows colder — and more disturbing.

Nancy Guthrie vanished without a trace on February 1 after failing to show up at a friend’s home. Inside her Tucson residence, investigators found her phone, keys, wallet, and medications untouched — a chilling sign that she may have been taken against her will.

Surveillance footage later revealed a masked man lurking outside her home, carrying a backpack in the early morning hours. Despite the eerie video, the suspect has yet to be identified, leaving investigators chasing leads with no clear breakthrough.

But the controversy surrounding Sheriff Nanos didn’t begin with this case — and insiders say that’s part of the problem.

The department has reportedly issued multiple votes of no confidence against him over the years, with one source noting this latest backlash “should not have surprised him at all.”

Former Pima County Lieutenant Bob Krygier pointed to a staggering statistic: years before Nancy’s disappearance, roughly 98 percent of officers voted no confidence in Nanos’ leadership.

“Think about that number,” Krygier said. “We’re not a small agency. We need to do better.”

Now, calls for accountability are growing louder — and more public.

Pima County Supervisor Dr. Matt Hines didn’t mince words, urging Nanos to step down immediately to restore trust in the department. He also raised concerns about the sheriff’s past disciplinary record, alleging multiple suspensions over issues ranging from tardiness to serious on-duty incidents.

“That’s a really troubling record,” Hines said, going as far as calling Nanos “a bad cop.”

With pressure mounting from both inside and outside the department, some fear the chaos at the top could be crippling the investigation when time matters most.

Meanwhile, Nancy Guthrie remains missing — and her family is still waiting for answers.

As the case spirals into controversy, one haunting question remains: is the investigation failing because of the mystery… or because of the man leading it?

By What's Up Today Editorial Team

The What’s Up Today Editorial Team covers breaking news, crime, pop culture, celebrity news, viral stories, human-interest features and other timely events from across the United States and around the world. Our reporting is based on information from official statements, court and public records, law enforcement agencies, government sources, primary-source social media posts, interviews and established local and national news organizations. Whenever possible, we verify key details through original sources and add useful context such as timelines, prior developments, court dates, official responses and what may happen next. We aim to clearly distinguish confirmed facts from allegations, opinion and speculation, especially in stories involving criminal investigations, lawsuits or developing events. If new information becomes available, our stories may be updated to reflect the latest verified details. Readers can contact the What’s Up Today Editorial Team through our Contact Us page with corrections, story tips or questions about our coverage.

Leave a Reply