Panic swept through a California gas station on Sunday after what appeared to be a teddy bear made of human skin was found abandoned near the entrance. Law enforcement roped off the area, fearing the grotesque figure might involve actual human remains.
But as it turns out — the bear was fake. Just horrifyingly realistic.
On July 13, San Bernardino County deputies responded to the AMPM at 13600 Bear Valley Road in Victorville after a 911 caller reported what they believed to be a mutilated body or body part outside the store. Officers cordoned off the parking lot, and a coroner’s investigator was dispatched to examine the grisly-looking plush.
“At first glance, it looked disturbingly real,” one bystander told local media. “I thought someone left a murder scene behind.”
But by nightfall, the truth emerged: the “human skin teddy bear” was actually a latex art prop sold online by a South Carolina horror artist — and part of a twisted prank.
The bear’s creator, Robert Kelly of Dark Seed Creations, is no stranger to controversy. Known for his grotesque, ultra-realistic props used in haunted houses and horror films, Kelly confirmed the bear was one of his. It sells for $165 on Etsy and is part of his “Flesh and Stitch” series.
“I ship these all the time to horror fans,” Kelly told PEOPLE in an email. “But I had no clue someone would drop one outside a gas station like that. Definitely not part of the plan.”
Kelly posted a video of the now-infamous bear on Facebook the same day, acknowledging that the Victorville incident had set off a firestorm.
“Every artist wants credit,” he wrote. “So I said, yep, I made that bear. But no, I wasn’t in on the prank.”
Still, Kelly admitted he wasn’t exactly upset.
“I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t enjoying the buzz just a little,” he told ABC7. “I mean, it’s horror art. If it’s scaring people, it’s working.”
Despite the bear turning out to be latex, the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department is still investigating the incident. It’s unclear if the person who left the bear could face any criminal charges.
“I don’t know if the guy broke any laws or if it was just a prank,” Kelly added. “But he definitely got some people riled up.”
So far, no arrests have been made, and police haven’t publicly identified who dropped the bear off.
Kelly’s “human skin” creations have become a hit in the horror prop world. The artist says his pieces — molded from latex and painted to mimic flayed flesh — are often used in haunted houses and film productions. But this is the first time one of his props caused a full-blown law enforcement response.
“It’s not real skin,” Kelly reiterated in interviews. “It’s just art — creepy, nightmare-inducing art.”
Authorities are still reviewing surveillance footage and trying to identify the prankster. Meanwhile, Kelly’s store has seen a boost in attention, with orders reportedly pouring in.
“If nothing else,” one fan wrote under Kelly’s Facebook post, “this is the best accidental marketing campaign ever.”
As for the gas station employees? They’re just hoping the next bear is stuffed with cotton, not screams.

Sick latex art
Anything for buck!