In a fiery critique, former Vanity Fair editor Tina Brown has taken aim at Meghan Markle’s new Netflix cooking show. Brown, a long-time royal insider, insists that the Duchess of Sussex has missed every mark.
“She has an unerring instinct for getting it wrong,” Brown declared on her Substack newsletter.
Brown’s verdict was blunt. Meghan, 43, is labeled “too damn impatient” and “behind the curve.” The former Suits star, according to Brown, has yet to craft a convincing persona. She even went so far as to say Meghan’s only chance would have been to admit, “what a flaming flop the last five years have been.”
A Royal Misstep in the Age of Netflix
Meghan’s show, With Love, Meghan, premiered on March 4 after a delay caused by California wildfires. Early ratings are far from impressive—526,000 households tuned in within the first five days, a stark contrast to the 2.1 million viewers for her previous series, Harry & Meghan.
Brown’s criticisms don’t stop at the screen. She lambasts Meghan and Prince Harry for their decision to partner with Netflix instead of staying connected to traditional royal engagements. “All Meghan had to do was shut up and wait,” Brown remarked. “Go quiet for a couple of years, start a family, and watch the royal real estate roll in.”
Branding Blunders and Trademark Troubles
The controversy deepens with Meghan’s recent rebranding. Once known as American Riviera Orchard, her lifestyle brand is now being rechristened as As Ever. Brown noted, “Who announces a new lifestyle brand and hounds celebrity friends to praise a strawberry jam without checking on the trademark?”
This rebrand follows a rejected trademark application by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office in September 2024 and a protest from Harry & David. Insiders describe the move as an embarrassing attempt to deflect a mounting disaster.
A Divided Audience and Uncertain Future
Netflix executives are nervous. Despite a second season renewal, concerns over low ratings and poor reviews are mounting. Industry giants like The Hollywood Reporter and Variety have slammed the show as a “Montecito ego trip,” where guests are forced to heap praise on Meghan.
Many American conservatives see this as a glaring miscalculation. They value traditional restraint and competence—a stark contrast to what they view as Meghan’s impulsive chase for fame. One observer remarked, “In Trump’s America, where blunt honesty and accountability are prized, this show feels out of step.”
Final Thoughts
Brown sums it up: “Meghan has come out with a show about fake perfection just when the zeitgeist has turned raucously against it.”
For a woman who once had the potential to be a transformative figure, Meghan Markle’s leap into Netflix appears to be a high-stakes gamble that is yet to pay off. The stark divide between her ambitions and traditional royal decorum is now on full display.

Wish Meghan was just go away already!
I bet she had to BEG for her “friends” to be on this travesty of a show…She has NO FRIENDS to speak of, either they found out her true nature or she used them and then ghosted them when their influence wore out, or they didn’t help her. Where’s Oprah and Venus? Did she ghost them and now they’re staying FAR AWAY after learning the truth we all knew about her???