A former Playboy model is shedding light on what she describes as an “extremely awkward” and unsettling experience during an appearance on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert—a moment that recently resurfaced and reignited debate over how female guests are treated in Hollywood.
A Moment Gone Wrong on Live TV
Sarah McDaniel, a 29-year-old model who gained fame as the cover star of Playboy’s first non-nude issue in 2016, was invited onto The Late Show that same year to discuss her sudden rise to prominence. But instead of a lighthearted conversation, she claims she was left feeling “humiliated” by Colbert’s comments and actions during the interview.
Wearing a stylish but revealing brown sleeveless tube dress, McDaniel found herself repeatedly adjusting the neckline to maintain her comfort. Rather than moving past the issue, Colbert seized on it, making remarks that some now view as inappropriate.
“Can I get you some duct tape or a poncho?” Colbert quipped as she tried to reposition her dress. “Are you cold? I just want to make sure. I would be cold if I was wearing that right now.”
Later in the segment, as McDaniel demonstrated selfie techniques, Colbert went a step further—holding up a sheet of white paper in front of her chest, an apparent attempt to cover her up.
The exchange left McDaniel visibly uncomfortable, and years later, she candidly discussed the incident during a 2021 livestream with political commentator Hasan Piker.
“It was extremely awkward, probably the worst moment of my life,” McDaniel admitted.
Piker, reacting to the footage, was taken aback. “That’s kind of messed up,” he said. “He only focused on that element.”
McDaniel agreed, adding, “Do you think he would be able to do that with a Hollywood actress? No way. It was because I was a nobody.”
Public Reaction: Harmless Banter or Inappropriate Behavior?
Following the resurfacing of the clip, public opinion remains divided. Some defended Colbert, arguing that he was merely attempting to diffuse an uncomfortable wardrobe mishap with humor.
“I feel so bad for her—that must have been so awkward,” one commenter wrote. “But I feel like he did a good job at making light of it.”
Others, however, viewed the exchange differently, with one user stating, “That was by far the most awkward interview I have ever seen him do.”
“He wouldn’t have done that to a mainstream actress,” another commented. “He treated her like a joke.”
The Broader Conversation on Late-Night Culture
The incident raises larger questions about how female guests—particularly models, influencers, and social media personalities—are treated in the entertainment industry. While late-night talk shows are designed to be comedic, critics argue that moments like these highlight an underlying bias in how women are perceived and respected in media spaces.
McDaniel, who has since built a career beyond modeling with acting credits in projects like SuperHigh and Septaria, seems to have moved on. But the resurfacing of this interview serves as a stark reminder of the fine line between humor and discomfort—especially when the power dynamics favor the host.
Whether Colbert himself will address the controversy remains to be seen. But as more past interviews come under scrutiny, the conversation around late-night television’s treatment of women is far from over.

She brought that on herself by wearing an inappropriate, too revealing “dress, and he should not have drawn more attention to it either.