A former college soccer standout, 31-year-old Matthew Hertgen, now faces first-degree murder, weapons charges, and animal cruelty counts. Authorities say he killed his 26-year-old brother, Joseph, and their pet cat.
Princeton Police rushed to the luxurious Michelle Mews Apartments on Saturday. A frantic 911 call reported a fire and a dead body. Officers arrived to find Matthew—the very person who dialed 911—inside the residence. There, they discovered the lifeless body of Joseph and a dead cat.
The Hertgen brothers grew up in the coastal town of Toms River. Their upbringing was marked by privilege. Raised by multi-millionaire parents, David and Debra Hertgen, they lived in a four-bedroom mansion with a pool. Their father runs WiLine Networks—a tech firm pulling in millions in revenue.
Both brothers shone on the soccer field. Matthew dazzled at Wesleyan University (2011–2014) and Joseph made his mark at the University of Michigan (2016–2019). They were local heroes from Toms River North High School.
Preliminary reports reveal brutal details. “The evidence shows severe blunt force trauma and multiple lacerations,” a Mercer County prosecutor said. “Joseph was pronounced dead at the scene.” A police spokesperson added, “This case is as tragic as it is shocking. We are still investigating the motive behind this heinous act.”
Joseph, a 2020 graduate with a degree in Business Administration, was employed as a banker and analyst at Locust Point Capital. His friends describe him as “the best of the best” and “a great soccer player and person.” Social media is awash with heartfelt tributes.
The incident unfolded in a luxurious building in downtown Princeton. Michelle Mews Apartments offers high-end living with monthly rents over $6,200. The building is nestled in Palmer Square Residences, just minutes away from an Ivy League community.
Authorities have yet to determine a clear motive. The autopsy is pending, and investigators are piecing together the events of that fateful night. The community remains stunned as more details are expected to surface in the coming days.

What On Earth! This Is So Sad.. I Just Can’t Imagine, What Was This About.. The Parent’s Must Be Beside Themselves … Losing One, BUT Possibly Two..