A longtime Arkansas pastor, known for his dedication to faith and community, is now at the center of a disturbing criminal case. Charles Thessing, 63, was arrested on February 11 and charged with two counts of aggravated cruelty to animals. Authorities allege he drowned two cats, a claim that has left his congregation in shock.
Thessing, who has served as a pastor at St. Michael Church in West Memphis for years, was taken into custody after the local animal shelter reported alleged acts of cruelty. Police say they found evidence at his home but have yet to release further details.
The arrest has rocked the tight-knit church community, where Thessing was widely respected for his years of service. Parishioners described him as a kind and generous man, often leading efforts to help struggling families and bring people closer to God.
“I just can’t believe it,” said longtime church member Mary Dawson, 72. “He baptized my grandchildren. He was there when my husband passed. This doesn’t sound like the man we know.”
Bishop Anthony B. Taylor of the Diocese of Little Rock announced Thessing’s suspension following the arrest, pending the outcome of the investigation. In a statement, the bishop called the allegations “disturbing” but acknowledged the pastor’s deep ties to the community.
“He has many supporters — many whose lives he has positively impacted,” Taylor said. “During this difficult time, I would ask every person of goodwill, both Father Thessing’s supporters and detractors, to keep him, your parishes, and your school in your prayers.”
Public reaction has been mixed, with some expressing shock and others urging patience as the legal process unfolds.
“I believe in innocent until proven guilty,” said Jim Robertson, a West Memphis resident and churchgoer. “It’s easy to rush to judgment, but we don’t know all the facts yet.”
Thessing has since been released on bond, according to local reports. It remains unclear whether he has entered a plea or retained legal counsel.
As the case moves forward, the community remains divided—some standing by their pastor, others struggling to reconcile the man they knew with the accusations he now faces. What’s certain is that this case will continue to be watched closely, both in Arkansas and beyond.
