Amanda Seyfried’s exploration of her family history on PBS’ Finding Your Roots uncovered a chilling and emotional revelation: her third great-grandfather, John P. Ebert, was brutally murdered in 1905. The shocking details emerged during the season 11 premiere, leaving the actress stunned.
“This is surreal. How could this happen?” Seyfried exclaimed, her voice trembling as she read from an old newspaper article detailing the crime. According to the report, Ebert, a retired baker beloved in his community, was shot three times by an unknown assailant. The attack occurred at 9:30 p.m. as he approached his back door, only to be ambushed by a figure lurking in the shadows of a grape arbor.
“Your third great-grandfather was murdered,” confirmed host Henry Louis Gates Jr., his tone grave as he guided Seyfried through the historical account. The actress, visibly shaken, responded, “It’s weird — I don’t know him, but yet, he’s family. How dare they? It makes me want to find justice, even after all these years.”
The details were heartbreaking. A local newspaper at the time described Ebert as “inoffensive” and “a good citizen.” Yet his life ended in violence, the case shrouded in mystery and left unsolved. Gates noted the profound impact such stories can have on descendants. “Events like these shape family narratives, often in ways we can’t immediately see,” he explained.
Seyfried’s shock turned to determination as she absorbed the gravity of the story. “It’s made me think about how stories like these shape us. Even if we don’t know them, they’re part of who we are,” she reflected. The discovery brought a mix of grief, curiosity, and a yearning for justice.
The upcoming season of Finding Your Roots promises more jaw-dropping revelations. Alongside Seyfried, an impressive lineup of celebrities delves into their ancestries, uncovering tales of survival, triumph, and heartache. Joy Behar, Kristen Bell, Laurence Fishburne, Debra Messing, and Chrissy Teigen are among the featured guests, each with stories that could rival Seyfried’s in intrigue.
“We could produce episodes every week for a year and still have more stories to tell,” Gates shared in an earlier interview, emphasizing the endless depth of family history.
For Seyfried, this shocking discovery is more than just a piece of history—it’s a call to reflect on the connections that bind generations. The emotional weight of her ancestor’s murder will undoubtedly linger as a defining chapter in her family’s story.

Seriously! Her 3rd great-grandfather? Seems more like a bid for attention to me. What a puff piece, written like a starry eyed groupie.